i think you would need a good filter system as shrimps are sensitive to changes in water perimeters.
its an interesting concept though would like to see how it turns out.

Hiya my name is Jodie.
I want to set up a brand new shrimp tank. (Red Cherry Shrimp) I have a small beta tank at the moment but I am still completely new to this hobby.
I want to keep the shrimp in this large vase if possible, I have drawn a very rough design on paint so you can see my idea. So basically have substrate in the lower section of the vase in the middle and plant moss balls there and maybe some other plants, have sand/gravel/nothing? (not sure which is best) around the outer part of the base to level off the floor. Have a piece of driftwood either at the back or over the moss (depending on what i can find) in the bottom part of the tank, then have long tall plants to go up the center of the tall tube part of the vase (maybe also a slim piece of drift wood that i could attach moss too so the shrimp cam climb up those parts) And then have a filter in the bottom at the back and a bubble wand too.
Would this set up be ok for shrimp? And if not would it suit any other kind of aqua life? I really want to set this vase up as some kind of tank. The glass is thick and I have tested it before with a heater in and it was just fine. (Originally i brought this for my beta but I was told it would be unsuitable as he is a surface dweller and left him in his current tank)
If this design would work could you please tell me exactly (if possible) what I need to buy to best have this type of set up (Which plants, which brand of substrate/sand, what type of wood etc, which brand of bubble wands/filters, do I need any type of heater/cooler (Tried to look it up online but got mixed views on a lot of stuff) And what brand shall I buy for food as I have read some shrimp made foods are not actually suitable.
Also I have read up on the nitrogen cycle and I think I understand it but I am still unsure of what I would actually need to do with the tank day by day?
Any help would be appreciated, thank you![]()


i think you would need a good filter system as shrimps are sensitive to changes in water perimeters.
its an interesting concept though would like to see how it turns out.



Errhhmmm.... you can keep Cherry shrimps with a sponge filter powered by an air pump. The shape of the vase will make it difficult to use any other type of filters. Internal power filters will need to be maintained once in a while and once you put your decor and livestock in, it will be difficult to remove the filter for maintenance. Shrimps are sensitive to sudden changes in water parameters so it's fine if you acclimatize them slowly. If you happen to be using a sponge filter you can do away with the bubble wand as well
I have kept Cherries in temperatures of 24 degree Celsius to 31 degree Celsius before and I would say they do better when the temperature are below 28 degrees Celsius. If your ambient temperatures are between 20 to 30 degree Celsius then you don't really need any heating or cooling. Substrate wise you can just use medium grade gravel. I would think this is intended to be a low maintenance tank so you can try using Java moss, Java Fern and Anubias tied to hard surfaces like driftwood. As for tall plants.... maybe Vallisneria spiralis would work with lower light although it wouldn't grow as fast. Once your tank is cycled, daily maintenance will be to feed the shrimps
I've never really tried keeping shrimps with just a sponge filter alone so I'm not too sure how efficient those things are. I have gone for 2 months without water change before when I was using a hang on filter. Just top up any water loss from evaporation with distilled water every other day. When doing bigger water changes, it might be better to slowly drip in dechlorinated water rather than just dumping it into the tank. Smaller volumes of water are more susceptible to parameter changes when doing water change.
I guess this would resemble those shrimp-in-a-bottle type setups, though the tall narrow neck of the vase would seem to make it rather tricky to scape layouts at the bottom of it.
The main issue i see with your vase is the very limited water surface area for oxygen exchange. If you were to put an internal filter or air stone in it, the wire will need to trail in from the top too and it'll look abit odd.
In addition, the vase has a cylindrical shape, which tends to really distort viewing, some people get dizzy looking at fishes or shrimps through those type of uneven glass shapes.![]()

I posted this same topic on another site and they have recommended a lot of the same stuff as youThe main difference being that they said because im only keeping shrimp in there the tank wont need to be cycled? I have read up on cycling and understand the basics of how it works, im just not sure what I have to do day by day? I also asked in the pet store and they said I wouldn't have to cycle it but I know alot of shop staff can be ill informed.. what do you think? As for temperature I live in the midlands in England, and the vase will be kept by a window, will this be suitable? there will be no direct sunlight on it but the temperature could maybe be affected? I have my betta fish on the same window and he seems fine. Here's a photo of the vase with a plant and a bit of water in just to give an idea, I wont be using this plant though.
I've also added a photo of my fish MangoIve taken the gravel out of his tank as it seemed to be hurting his fins, when I go to get the shrimp gear i'm hoping to get some stuff to improve his tank too, any recommendations? Real plants etc?
From what I've gathered from the other forums heres the list of things I plan on using for the vase tank, do you see any issues with any of these or know of anything better?
http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B...=AR53ZFM038NSR
http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B...A11T4VJCN1FUWG
http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B...A1OTCX5XU7DWJ4
http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B...A1IIEY7ME54BIO
That equipment, then with black sand over the whole base to bring out the colour of the shrimps, then have the filter in the middle, with the longer plants placed around the back of the filter in the dipped part and moss balls in the front, then maybe a few small plants around the outer base like small grass like plants?
Then either add live or fake plants going up the tube to hide the wires. What do you think?

The neck of the vase is fairly wide, I have managed to set things up in their before as a testI was also recommended to attach my plants to rocks to make them easier to manoeuvre
If you can read my ideas in the previous post do you think that would be ok? (Would the filter ive chosen be ok for the oxygen issue?)
Also I was unsure about the distortion too, I'm hoping it will magnify the shrimp if anything making them easier to see, I have posted a photo with a plant in their so you can see what it would look like, I think it will be ok. I really want to give this a try, if it fails then so be it and I will buy a normal tank.



Well... you might be able to get away with not cycling your tank but I won't vouch for the survivability of your shrimps in that case. They do better in an established tank rather than an uncycled one after all. The nitrogen cycle is self sustaining once established. As long as there is ammonia, the cycle will sustain itself. Usually you don't have to perform daily tasks to maintain it if there are live stocks like shrimps or fish inside. Just make sure you don't overfeed them and it should be fine. I can't comment on the equipment you've chosen, so far I've been using normal equipment for regular shaped tanks but they should do fine.
Oh... England then you'll definitely need a heater for winter. I have no idea how hot it gets in Summer over there but you can get a thermometer and monitor the current temperatures first. If the tank doesn't constantly go above 32 degrees Celsius then I think it's fine. Regarding the oxygen level the bubbles from sponge filters will help agitate the surface to improve oxygen exchange so that's about the best you can do. I wouldn't worry too much about the oxygen level unless you are keeping a lot of shrimps. Plants wise I've already mentioned in my previous post for low requirement plants. It's a simple set up and doesn't cost that much. Just go ahead and try!
One thing to note though... Cherry Shrimps do reproduce really fast
Oh yeah, you do need an air pump and a return check valve![]()
Things to take note.
1. Cycle your tank. Read up on nitrogen cycle.
2. Shrimp are not like betta which can stand harsh water change.
3. A sponge filter is recommend.
Bookmarks