most likely due high water temperature...
btw, what's ur tank temperature?

Currently i have a setup of 2ft by 1ft by 1.5ft tank. Planted deformis, cabomba and riccia. CO2 having 2.5 bubbles per second, 8 hours of 48watts of light, no fishes. Sea chem flourite with ocean free base. setup for 5 days and my cabomba, riccia and deformis edge of the leaves are slowly melting, not turning yellow but grey color. I just placed sea chem's nitrogen, phospous, potassium, traces and ferropol iron 2 days ago. The plants are bubbling by the way but i would like to know what is causing the plants to melt or distinegrate? I havent do any test about the water and will do it this weekend.
Photography: The light that that shines the path![]()
Aquarium: The path that leads to Light![]()
Together I give you Aquagraphy.
most likely due high water temperature...
btw, what's ur tank temperature?



red cabomba is really sensitive to heat.. i've given up on them. try the green ones, they look great and more hardy..
There will be no more deaths after the holocaust. Of course, having 3 fishes in my 400L tank helps.

room temperature. I have a fan but i am very doubtful in using it. Cause currentlu i have a jebao canister running at 1000L which is way too fast for my 2ft tank. Even when i put a sponge at the bottom of my reactor, The co2 still doesnt fully dissolve but gets thrown out of the outlet in very small bubble forms. So i didnt want to use the fan to create more current and dissolving the CO2. Any help in this and the Green cabomba distinegrating.
Photography: The light that that shines the path![]()
Aquarium: The path that leads to Light![]()
Together I give you Aquagraphy.

That's your problem, room temperature is too hot for a planted tank. Along with 48W of light... your temp will be above 28 degrees celcius, possibly 30 degrees which is not good news for plants.
Using a fan won't affect your CO2 dissolution much, just set it to the same timer as the lights.
Believe me, adding fans will free you from those melting plant problems...
Then you can move to other problems, maybe algae problems![]()






Not enough nutrients....temperature is over emphasized imo (this plants can and do grow fine in warm waters). I run mine tank without fans though but the light was raised to about 10-12cm above the tank.
Regards
Peter Gwee![]()
but he is dosing fertiliser and his plants are bubbling?
maybe his tank is really warm... like more than 30°C ?
Anyway, yea... as |squee| said, using a fan won't affect dissolved CO2 levels...![]()
But, using a canister filter that you yourself said was too fast will definitely dissipate the dissolved CO2 in your tank, due to the water turbulence it causes...
so u might want to change your filter.
and add a fan; have to top up water frequently though.
if u have lots of money, can consider a chiller too![]()
also get a thermometer? and be obsessed with water temperature...
or just find other plants that thrive in your current tank conditions![]()






How often? I do grow those plants before and my temperature is around 30-32 degrees celsius with no issues.
Regards
Peter Gwee![]()

Hi Peter,Originally Posted by PeterGwee
I tried to grow the Hygro and Camboba before in the past without a fan, and the water temperature went up to 30-32 during those hotter days.
However I was using 3x 20W FL tubes then over a 38gallon tank.
If we have PL lighting over the same tank, won't it get too high like 34deg during middays ?
~Chyrl~
向来如此便是对吗?
Live each moment like its the last






Is the light set using E-ballast? Those iron-core types do run hotter which can make a difference.Originally Posted by cs_sg
Regards
Peter Gwee![]()

Yes. Using the PL lightings with E-ballast.Originally Posted by PeterGwee
May I know the highest temperature these plants can tolerate?
~Chyrl~
向来如此便是对吗?
Live each moment like its the last






Perharps 36-38 degrees...not sure. (Why push it to the limits?)
Regards
Peter Gwee![]()

Just want to be prepared how tolerant these few 'easier' plants are to higher temperature. Guess the best indicator is still the tell tale signs from the plants itself.Originally Posted by PeterGwee
Thanks for sharing![]()
~Chyrl~
向来如此便是对吗?
Live each moment like its the last






Hygro Difformis, cabomba and riccia are all fast growers and nutrient hogs. Its always something major for them to melt. The plants are pearling tells you they are fixing carbon and hence nutrients will be uptaken as well. You note that Discman just added nutrients (not sure if he add any before that) and he needs to continue in order for things to bounce back (how long depending on how badly things are stunted.). Plants need 3 things to grow....light, CO2 and nutrients. Focus on those things first and make sure they are non-limiting before going somewhere else. All I can say is yes, plants do better with colder temperatures but most can grow fine in warm waters as well.
Regards
Peter Gwee![]()

thanks guys for the advise and help, Squee, I will try the fan method first but would like to know usually ppl put horizontally parallel with the water or about 45 degree to the water for the fan?
Peter thanks for your help too. as you read i dose the nutrients 3 days ago, 1 day for marco nutrient and 1 day for traces with the amount stated on the bottle. Although i know seachem is know to be diluted but i believe it wouldnt be so diluted that you will be required to dos twice the amount stated inorder to get good results.
Will see the results for the next 3 days before deciding. By the way do you guys remove the melted plants or leave it there?
Photography: The light that that shines the path![]()
Aquarium: The path that leads to Light![]()
Together I give you Aquagraphy.
Better remove the melted part, so the plants can grow faster & not stunted.![]()




how about weak stems and leaves comming off easily? lack of nutrients or CO2?
Bookmarks