If cost is a concern, do not go for eheim!


Hi guys.
I'm new here and i have a 1.5' x 1' x 1' planted tank that's about 2 months already and i've recently bought a 28" x 19" x 17" tank that can take approx. 150litres. will put up some pictures soon.
i'm planning to buy an external filter like eheim but just to ask you guys about the recommended capacity of the filter for my 150litre tank.
some LFS suggest doubling the intake of the filter compared to my tank which is 300litre but i find the price increase is quite expensive. however another LFS suggest 150-250litre should be just fine.
just to compare, an eheim 2213 (150-250litres) cost RM250 . an eheim ecco (300litre) cost RM500.
any comments are appreciated. thanks.

If cost is a concern, do not go for eheim!





Wah..Eheim is abit ex in malaysia...
I think 2213 is good enough for a 2ft tank..


cost actually not a problem. the main thing is if my tanks is 150litre will it be sufficient if i go for a 150litre or 200litre capacity filter or should i double the capacity?
It will be good that the flowrate is around 3 or 4 times the volume of your tank.
Eg. If your tanks is 150L, you should be looking at a filter with flowrate between 450L-600L/hr.
Hope this helps!
We use no flow rate less than 4 times lph than volume of tank tried a 600 lph on 3ft and it just manages the job. If the price diffrence is so great might consider 2 smaller pumps/filters?


that means that if my tank holds 150litres then i should aim for a 600l/h capacity filter? is that normal? what about a 400l/h filter?Originally Posted by kalindab
if 600l/h then i should buy a eheim ecco 2236 filter. anyone care to share their experience using this filter? thanks.

Go straight to a 2026... Overfiltering is good.. And you can control the outflow using this filter too...


isn't 2026 a bit overkill for my measly 150litre tank?

I going to use 2026 on a 81litre tank... What do you think?
I know of someone who uses a 2028 on a 54litre tank!
Your tank is definitely NOT miserly... If you going to use a chiller or reactor in future, you will be glad that you chose a 2026 instead of an Ecco...![]()

2026 is good for a 3 feet tank. In fact, i will not use a single 2026 if i upgrade from a 3 feet tank. again, my connection is Skimmer>Filter>Chiller>reactor>tank

I believe that it all works out to be what your requirements are. If you have a heavy bioload then maybe you want many times overfiltering. But if you choose the 2213, it has a flowrate of 440 l/h according the website. It is already about 3 times and may be sufficient for the bioload.Originally Posted by Spawnster
Also, do you intend to connect a chiller to it in the future? If you do then you might want to get a more powerful one as the flowrate is significantly reduced when you connect a chiller to it. If you intend to go for the 2236 then you might as well seriously consider the 2026 if the price difference is not too much.
Have you looked at this yet?
http://www.eheimasiapacific.com/Engl...ages/chart.jpg


thanks for your input guys. anyways i don't plan to use a chiller any time soon. just the normal pc type fan cos i can get constant 25-26degrees with it.
i guess more is better than less right?

Nope, there's the certain rate at how fast water can evaporate by blowing fans on it. Max 2 fans imho. I have 2 fans because I use them for 2 functions: to cool the water and to cool the lightset.
2026 is just about right for a 3ft planted tank. One of my 3ft tanks is running on a ehiem 2228 which is just about right for this tank cos it's a pleco tank and i'm sure you know the amt of wastes they produce.
Getting a filter with higher flow rate is better in the long run cos don't need to upgrade to a bigger one if later you want to change to a bigger tank or want to have a higher stocking density for that tank.
Also over filteration is always better than under filteration.
Hi,
Just a little comment. The downside of a filter with a high flow rate is that it could create too strong currents in the tank. However, there are ways, such as directing the flow against the tank wall or using taps, to mitigate this concern.![]()
Yup... agreed, the best is directing the flow against the tank wall. I don't use taps to slow down the flowrate because i'm afraid that it'll spoil the filter in the long run cos i feel that if the filter is made to run on a specific flowrate than it's better not to tamper with it by slowing it down.


yeah was worried about that too. thanks for the tip. since it's a planted tank, too strong a current wouldn't be good for the plants right?
Hi,
Agree with aquarius that we should avoid using taps to lower the flow. Another option would be to use rainbars.
Generally, the current should not be so large as to prevent plants from staying rooted, stirring up too much debris, presenting too much of a swimming challenge for your fishes, etc. On the flip side, good circulation is essential to distribute CO2 and nutrients in order to avoid dead spots in your tank. You'll have to find a good balance.![]()


yeah really worried whether the flow rate for 2236 would be too strong for my 2.5' tank. any of you have exactly the same set-up?
Bookmarks