Thinking of bring a few kgs of Shirakura soil back to singapore this weekend but don't know how good it is. Anyone tried Shirakura soil? How good is it as compared to ADA Amazonia or Amazonia II in terms of nutrients, stability, etc? All I know is it doesnt cloud the water and cost double of ADA Amazonia in HK.
Cheers,
Chee Wei
From Sarawak: C.Pallidinervia, C.Bullosa, C.Keei, C. Yujii, Barcalaya sp.From Peninsula Malaysia: C.nurii, C.cordata, C.afinnis, C.minima, C.purpurea, C.eliptica
Bettas: b. ideii, b. macrostoma, b. pallifina, b. ocellata, b. channoides
Never heard of it. I have 2 cube tanks with ADA AS and the clouding lasted only at most a week for both tanks, and my water is crystal clear now. IMHO ADA AS is a very good product already. Unless it does twice better than ADA AS, I would not even think twice about investing twice as much for another product.
Chee wei, why not try it out personally since i think this product is still relatively new to many hobbyist. And many of us will somehow benefited from hearing your comments too.
Maybe some who have tried can share some comments.
The Happiest of people don't neccessary have the best of everything;
they just make the most of everything that comes along their way
When will there be 25 letters in the alphabets?
To compare, I have to set up 3 tanks here in HK.. 1 Shirakura, 1 ADA Amazonia and 1 ADA Amazonia II. I thought can go by short cut by asking here..
Cheers,
Chee Wei
From Sarawak: C.Pallidinervia, C.Bullosa, C.Keei, C. Yujii, Barcalaya sp.From Peninsula Malaysia: C.nurii, C.cordata, C.afinnis, C.minima, C.purpurea, C.eliptica
Bettas: b. ideii, b. macrostoma, b. pallifina, b. ocellata, b. channoides
Hi Chee Wei, why don't you check with the folks at AquaticStore in Tung Choi?
He should be able to give you some information.
It's NOT "Chee lick", NOT "Chee Chee Licks"!!! Cichlids is pronounced as "Sick Lids"!!!!!
Hi Yorky,
Which one is Aquaticstore? I usually remember the location but never check the names. So far 2 LFSs there told me it is much better in terms of stability, nutrients and wont turn to mud as fast as ADA. I don't know how true it is because they are the sellers.I am very reluctant to set up any fish tank here in HK because I don't know how long I am going to be here. Everytime I see the price of ADA products here, I feel very tempted.
Cheers,
Chee Wei
From Sarawak: C.Pallidinervia, C.Bullosa, C.Keei, C. Yujii, Barcalaya sp.From Peninsula Malaysia: C.nurii, C.cordata, C.afinnis, C.minima, C.purpurea, C.eliptica
Bettas: b. ideii, b. macrostoma, b. pallifina, b. ocellata, b. channoides
Hi cwtan12,
I can't write the chinese name.. but its "Shui Chao Dian" or translated as Aquatic Plant Store.
He doesn't sell the accessories so you might get frank opinions from him.
It's NOT "Chee lick", NOT "Chee Chee Licks"!!! Cichlids is pronounced as "Sick Lids"!!!!!
yeh, ADA Amazonia not bad, but too easy to break
水草店? Should be shui cao dianOriginally Posted by yorky
Want to learn more so that i can give back...
Yippie!! Reptiles and Fishies!
i don't know if singapore already has ADAII but have been hearing good things about it so far.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks