What about the substrates from Dennerle? I think David, our senior moderator is currently using it.
(ps: just prelimary work for a substrate faq, bored in the office)
What's available in singapore?
Seachem Fluorite/Fluorite Red/Onyx
Nisso Volcamia Soil
Nisso Soil for Planted Tank (not sure of name, willcheck)
Taikho Active Soil for Hydro Terrarium
Hirose brand (not sure what...)
Azoo Plant Grower Bed
ADA Powersand/Amazonia/Africana etc (not readily available yet...let's hope biotope brings it in)
These are the so called "exotic" substrate material that can be found in Singapore.
Conventional tanks will be using
Lonestar/RMC Pacific Monterey sand covering a layer of base fertiliser (JBL Aquabasis/Deponit/Duplarit etc ).
Typically, people would be using the conventional method, however for people who are not cost conscious.
PRO's of using "exotic" substrate
a) Uniform substrate, you probably never have to deal with base fert leaching.
b) PH values for some (eg: Nisso are automatically 6.6 or 7.x) depending on which you buy. which makes it suitable for african cichlids or amazonian cichlids. Acidic soil I believe is good for plant growth as well.
CON's
a) the soil based types will breakdown into mud eventually (2-3 years) however, take into account that most aquarists tear down their tanks/change layouts by then, however, even if you do, its not a problem as long as you do your water changes with care.
b) Cost, they are expensive, typically in region of 40-55 per bag (7/8kg)





What about the substrates from Dennerle? I think David, our senior moderator is currently using it.






OK off hand you left out Dupla Laterite, and Dennerle Deponit substrates. Both are excellent as the many testimonies on the web can attest
Allen
Dupla Laterite, and Dennerle Deponit
^^^ are base ferts. ie: goes by basefert over gravel, <- as in nothing special at all..heh
denerlle quart gravel is an inert substance, you will need base fert to use ie: its just expensive colored sand.






Chris... OK maybe we need to clarify your terms...
For me gravel means lonestar etc...
Substrate means gravel + base ferts... which is why I mentioned dennerle and dupla.
Allen

Chris, you did not cover soil or compost base ferts.
Vincent - AQ is for everyone, but not for 'u' and 'mi'.
Why use punctuation? See what a difference it makes:A woman, without her man, is nothing.
A woman: without her, man is nothing.
ah. for me -> yucks, unhygienic, full of who knows what. and are you going to dig up the hdb land for soil??
This is singapore, where regular mosquito spraying goes on.
if they decide to charge you $100 psf lol..



Hi there,
Seems like some very cool substrate you guys are talking about. May I know where to get them?
Any way how about base fertilizer? How many types are there?
Hope here from all of you soon
Thanks
![]()
![]()
![]()

Chris,
No lah, I'm talking about the stuff sold at plant nurseries. The important thing is to make sure they don't contain and insecticides, pesticides and other chemical additives. The safest bet, IMO, is Arthur J Bower's Aquatic Compost which specifically says its safe for aquatic life. Not sure if there are other brands out there, but I suppose the nurseries can tell you whats ok for fishes in ponds.
Vincent - AQ is for everyone, but not for 'u' and 'mi'.
Why use punctuation? See what a difference it makes:A woman, without her man, is nothing.
A woman: without her, man is nothing.
azoo: found at lor halus (not sure which shop) and the new shop c328 polyart.
nisso,taikho,hirose: c328 has one type, the others are found at aquafauna (farmart)
seachem fluorite: aquamart (call to check) or petmart.
ada: no distribution in singapore.
base fert types (including aquatic compost) all have the posibilities of fert leaching into the water column, especially when you uproot plants. I guess one has to go down to the nitty gritty of the chemical composition of each brand.
I've never tried soil/compost types before, but if it really is compost, then its bound to have all kinds of organic debris in it.






I used cocopeat in two of my three tanks. It's made from shredded coconut husks as I read. So far doing well even when some of it leached into the water when I do replanting.
I believe these type of soil are not laden with any more fertilisers so the leaching into the water is not a problem.
Do commercial fertilisers cause any problem when they leach into the water? Stuff like JBL?
Check out this site with the most info on non-commercial substrates: Substrates for Aquarium Plants by Steve Pushak
koah fong
Juggler's tanks





Chris,----------------
On 1/4/2003 2:07:35 PM
(ps: just prelimary work for a substrate faq, bored in the office)
What's available in singapore?
ADA Powersand/Amazonia/Africana etc (not readily available yet...let's hope biotope brings it in)
----------------
The ADA Powersand is base-fert.![]()
Aquatic plants and LEGO collector.



Hi again,
I am using the black crystal type...not really as cool as what you people are using... but don't really know the name but seems nice to me.
Anyone knows the name... any experience to share with the type I am talking about.
Thanks
![]()
![]()
![]()
Bookmarks