Hi .. is the fish you have look something like the below? If so, then it's the false SAE.
![]()

Hi all..I just bought a pair of what I thought were SAE's from Neo Tiew. After looking at some net articles and pics, I am beginning to think that I just bought a bogus pair! The black line does not reach the tip of the tail and there is a glowy line above the black line. I am not sure if they are the "false siamensis". Or are there SAEs with the above description?
Anyone out there has the same experience of buying the wrong species from this LFS at Neo Tiew (can't disclose the name..)?
---------------------
So many fish, so little time...




Hi .. is the fish you have look something like the below? If so, then it's the false SAE.
![]()
NinjaFly
My fish hobby site

yok, guarantee salah liaoz.
why I don't do garden hybrids and aquarium strains: natural species is a history of Nature, while hybrids are just the whims of Man.
hexazona · crumenatum · Galleria Botanica

my fren help me get an sae from gan today and he forgot to check and it turned out to be fake too...

How about mine??? bought at Petmart!
![]()
Baby Steel!

limsteel, yours should be the correct one.
人的一生﹐ 全靠奮斗﹐ 唯有奮斗﹐ 才能成功
yep, limsteel, affirm yours is the genuine one too. noticed the black band extendall the way to the tail - that's the surefire way to recognise a SAE![]()

anakin, there is another fake SAE with black band all the way through to the tail, you also have to watch for a pale/gold stripe above the black band. In the true SAE the black band go all the way AND it is merge into the grey/brownish back scales in a "jagged" fashion.
why I don't do garden hybrids and aquarium strains: natural species is a history of Nature, while hybrids are just the whims of Man.
hexazona · crumenatum · Galleria Botanica
In anyway, they will soon be a nuisance. []
colin | The Wilderness and Forest | FTS

Ninjafly: That's the way the tail part looks but the bright strip above the black line is not so obvious. But I guess I confirm kena con already...
So what do you guys recommend I do with my 2 lookalikes? Too small to be eaten...[]
---------------------
So many fish, so little time...
hwchoy, thanks for the tips, anyway, true or not, my SAEs are totally spoilt and now eating more flakes than algae. Otos are still the more hardworking bunch, IMO [] My SAEs are the biggest fish in my tank now - some of them almost 4 inches long now. they're definitely a more graceful-looking (and mischievous) lot than Otos though

Hi,
Is it true that SAE eat plants too? not just algae? I saw my SAE eating fish food as well.
I suspect a plot of my riccia was actually wiped out by SAE.
So is my suspicion correct?

That may be possible.
SAE are known to nibble on young shoots of tender plants like mosses. Might be possible that SAE also wack riccia. Probably they are just too hungry or greedy.![]()
BC






SAE eat fish food as well, especially those bigger ones. Also known to sometimes nibble on plants with fine leaves.
koah fong
Juggler's tanks
Bookmarks